Impact Evaluation

SPRING is a five-year accelerator programme that supports business ventures to develop products and services to help girls earn, learn, save, keep safe and experience increased well-being. As one component of the overall evaluation of SPRING, the Impact Evaluation (IE) gathers Information on the economic and social outcomes of girls who benefit from products and services delivered by SPRING businesses.

Fightback is one of eight businesses that are included in the SPRING IE, and the third of the eight to have an end line report published. SPRING assisted Fightback to develop the Fightback Girls en-mass training programme to train hundreds of girls in a single session.

Coffey International a UK based Research Company and M&E partner of Spring for the impact evaluation of Cohort 2 business conducted the long term independent impact assessment. This groundbreaking study on the impact of self defense has been done for the first time in South Asia and 3rd in the world.

Impact Safety (& Learning) Wellbeing
Areas Direct benefit through training to improve safety awareness and self-defence skills; leading to safer behaviour change Direct benefit through improved confidence, peer network and agency; shift in shame and blame culture
Expected Impact High (5) High (4)
Actual Impact High (5) High (4)
Summary of impact

1

Improved feeling of situational safety and improved satisfaction with ability to keep themselves safe.

2

Improved knowledge of safety and self-defence techniques.

3

Improved rating of self-assessed psychological and physical health.

4

Improved satisfaction with friendships, self-confidence and satisfaction with life overall.

An Independent Impact Evaluation by Coffey International on the Fightback schools model was completed by July 2019. Results for n=1091 school girls is as follows.
(Quantitative)
The quantitative assessment was conducted by the independent evaluators. There are two components of quantitative data collection:
  1. The Pre/Post-training survey
  2. The baseline/endline survey

Increase in Self Defense Skills

96%

Increase in ability to stay away from Dangerous Situation

92%

Increase in Self Confidence

88%

Increase in ability to escape from possible threats

92%

Increase in feeling of safety

92%

Increase in alertness and active mind

92%
(Qualitative)
Qualitative assessment was conducted through the following tools

1

KIIs conducted with head teachers.

2

Paired KIIs with adolescent girls who participated in trainings, and separate KIIs with their guardians.

3

FGDs with adolescent girls who participated in trainings, and an additional FGD held with a comparable sample of boys who did not participate in training.

KIIs = Key Informant Interview

FDGs = Focus Group Discussion

Parent (student, age 18)

“Fightback training is not like other trainings that focus mostly on physical defense skills. Fightback training helps my daughter to be prepared psychologically, emotionally, mentally and physically to deal with any kind of possible harassments.”

Parent (student, age 18)

“For me, Fightback training will be the first priority among different extra-curricular activities. I think Fightback, as safety education, is the most important skill for my daughter and I will be more than willing to pay for this training than spending money on other ordinary activities.”

Student, age 17

“The training was so effective that it has made me confident and I feel I can deal with any kind of harassment.”

Student, age 19

“Yes, I feel safer in the last 6-8 months after the training, I feel safer than before as now I know how to avoid risky situations. I have now become more aware of my surroundings and if anything happens, I can push the person, shout and ask for help.”

Internal Impact Evaluation

We conducted training for 600 adolescent girls across 12 districts. We also conducted pre/post evaluations and conducted an impact assessment after 3 months with all trainees. A sample size of 600 adolescent girls across 12 districts produced the following results.

Impact

97.3%

Girls said that their self confidence increase

600 Adolescent Girls Trained Across 12 Districts

Mental Safety Skill Before the Program:4.69%

Mental Safety Skill After the Program:97.2%

Vocal Safety Skill Before the Program:4%

Vocal Safety Skill After the Program:94%

0% Physical Safety Skill Before the Program

After the Program 33% of Trainess got A Grade, 51% B Grade and 16% got C Grade on self Defense techniques

Increase in following Safety Skills

Increase in Detecting Earky Warning Signs of Sexual Voilence: 90%
Increase in Understanding Criminal Mindset: 93%
Increase in Understanding high Risk Zones: 965
Increase in Assertive Communication: 90%
Increase in Fear Mgmt. Skills: 91%
Increase in Identifying Vulnerable Area of a Potential Attacker: 92%
Increase in using day to day objects as improvised weapons: 91%
(Qualitative)
KII 1

This is the first time I’m taking such training. It was my mom who insisted to take this training. I was not very sure because I have to leave work to attend this training. But fortunately this training has become a life changing experience for me. I was a very shy girl with low self-confidence but now I feel confident and assertively talk to anyone who tries to harass me. This training is beneficial not just for us adolescent girls but for women as well. The formulas for safety will be of great use now and in the future. I will talk about this training to my friends, sisters and also my brothers.

KII 2

I have never enrolled this kind of training before but we need such trainings in our life. Most of the time, we used to be attacked, sexually harassed but we couldn’t do anything about it, we would quietly walk away but now we know how to verbally pacify the situation. Now after this training, we know the different techniques to safeguard ourselves in public vehicles as well. Well, we could forget a lot of other things but we could not forget about defending ourselves while being such vulnerable situations. Thus, we will never forget this training and will also help my friend and sisters against sexual violence.

KII 3

I learnt the methods and techniques to protect myself during sexual harassment, the different steps involved in defending myself, I learnt about criminal profiling, types of rapists, criminal mindset and how to avoid them and not get into situation where you could be harmed. We can always be prepared for any kind of situation and use the different kinds of techniques we learnt during the training and defend ourselves.